‹ Blog

Fear Index Hit 10 While Top Traders' Profits Nearly Doubled: Why Did Two Numbers Read the Same Drop in Opposite Ways?

Columns · · Satoshi Note Editorial

Read in: 한국어 · 日本語 · 中文

On the day market sentiment hit its lowest point, top traders' paper profits were at their highest.

At 9:00 a.m. Seoul time on November 11, the Crypto Fear & Greed Index stood at 29.

Four days later, on the 15th, it was 10. Ten out of 100: "Extreme Fear."

Over those four days, Bitcoin (BTC) fell 13.1%, from $73,771 to $64,122.

The Satoshi Index moved the other way. (The Satoshi Index is Satoshi Note's view of the open positions held by top-ranked traders on four perp exchanges: Hyperliquid, Lighter, dYdX and Pacifica.)

Unrealized profit in its 30-day group grew from about $253 million to $489 million, almost double.

Does that mean the pros stayed calm while everyone else panicked?

The interesting part is that the two numbers weren't looking at different things.

Fear and top-trader profit recorded the same sell-off in two different ways, and both are closer to a mirror of the past 30 days than a window onto the next.

At a glance

  • From November 11 to 15, the Fear & Greed Index fell from 29 to 10, while unrealized profit in the Satoshi Index 30-day group rose from about $253 million to $489 million.
  • The 30-day group is re-picked from the past 30 days' results. With BTC down 26% in a month, accounts holding shorts dominate the list; its long share stayed between 7.8% and 17.8% for all ten days.
  • Half of the Fear & Greed Index comes from volatility and price momentum. Neither number tells you where price goes next (as of November 20).

1. How the two numbers moved over ten days

Here are each morning's Fear & Greed reading, BTC price, and the Satoshi Index 30-day group side by side.

Date (morning, KST)Fear & GreedBTC30-day long share30-day unrealized PnL
Nov 1129$73,7719.7%+$253M
Nov 1228$73,98010.3%+$259M
Nov 1320$71,4489.5%+$285M
Nov 1413$68,2757.8%+$362M
Nov 1510$64,12210.8%+$489M
Nov 1610$65,33012.2%+$358M
Nov 1712$64,85817.8%+$233M
Nov 1811$64,92114.9%+$218M
Nov 1910$63,0379.7%+$275M
Nov 2012$61,9628.0%+$293M

The Fear & Greed value updates daily at 9:00 a.m. KST (00:00 UTC); BTC is the Hyperliquid price at that time. 30-day group figures come from that morning's daily snapshot (05:19–08:09 KST), except Nov 20, which is a 13:14 KST snapshot.

From the 11th to the 15th, the lower the fear reading went, the bigger the profit got.

On the morning of the 15th, when the index first touched 10, the 30-day group's unrealized profit was also at its ten-day high.

After that, while the index sat between 10 and 12, profit fell from $489 million to $218 million and then climbed again.

One number isn't in the table. The 30-day group's total short exposure shrank 31%, from about $2.45 billion on the 11th to about $1.68 billion on the 20th.

2. Did the pros simply not feel fear?

The first explanation that comes to mind is "the pros saw the drop coming and shorted it."

This data alone can't support that conclusion.

The 30-day group isn't a fixed set of people. For each exchange we re-pick the top 100 accounts by 30-day return and by 30-day profit at every snapshot. On November 20 that was 509 accounts.

BTC went from $84,041 on October 21 to $61,962 on November 20, down 26% in a month.

In a month like that, the accounts with the best results are mostly the ones that held shorts. A short-heavy list is a product of how the list is chosen.

So the 30-day group's long share of 7.8–17.8% across the ten days is hard to read as proof that these traders predicted the fall.

The short-window group, by contrast, behaved very differently. The 24-hour group's long share was 70.8% on the morning of the 12th and 79.6% on the morning of the 16th, when the fear index read 28 and 10.

A top-trader list records who got it right, not who stayed calm.

3. What the fear index actually measures

The Fear & Greed Index is a 0–100 score published once a day by alternative.me. Closer to 0 means fear; closer to 100 means greed.

Half of the score comes from price.

Volatility (25%) and volume plus momentum (25%) are compared with their 30- and 90-day averages. The rest is social media activity (15%), surveys (15%, currently paused), Bitcoin dominance (10%) and Google search trends (10%).

When price falls fast, the volatility and momentum components drop together. That's why the index tends to read low right after a sharp sell-off.

A CoinStats analysis published on November 16 made the same point. Since February 2018 the index has closed at or below 10 on 71 days. Grouped into 25 measurable clusters, the median BTC move over the following 90 days was +1.4%.

Fourteen of the 25 were higher, and outcomes ranged from −38.4% to +100%. CoinStats called it close to a coin flip, not a timing signal.

A reading of 10 tells you how rough the last 30 days were. It doesn't tell you about the next 90.

4. Price fell further, so why did profit shrink?

On the morning of November 20, BTC was at $61,962, the lowest of the ten days.

That's 3.4% below the morning of the 15th.

Yet the 30-day group's unrealized profit was $293 million, 40% less than the $489 million on the 15th.

You'd expect a short-heavy list to earn more as price falls.

There are two possibilities.

One is that shorts were closed and profit was locked in. Once profit is realized, it leaves the unrealized figure. That fits with short exposure falling from about $1.88 billion on the 15th to about $1.68 billion on the 20th.

The other is that the list changed. As the 30-day ranking is re-picked, accounts with large gains may have dropped out and others come in.

Snapshot totals alone can't separate the two.

A smaller unrealized profit doesn't mean anyone lost money; it's a reminder that a single number can't tell you what happened inside it.

5. What to separate when reading both together

When you hear that fear is at rock bottom while top traders are making money on shorts, it's tempting to think one of the two must be wrong.

That doesn't make either number useless. Together they clearly show how rough the past month was and which side got it right.

But three distinctions help avoid misreading them.

First, whose number is it? The fear index scores the mood of the whole market. The Satoshi Index shows actual positions of top accounts on four exchanges.

Second, how was the group chosen? The 30-day group is the accounts that did best over the past 30 days. Lots of shorts in a falling market may simply be a result of that selection.

Third, when was it measured? The fear index updates once a day; the Satoshi Index every 30 minutes. The table here uses one morning snapshot per day, so positions opened and closed in between don't appear.

Conclusion: fear and profit were two sides of the same drop

From November 11 to 15, the Fear & Greed Index fell from 29 to 10.

Over the same four days, unrealized profit in the 30-day top-trader group rose from $253 million to $489 million.

On the 20th, with price lower still, the index read 12 and unrealized profit was $293 million.

This record can't tell you when the fear will end, or which side top traders will take next.

What matters isn't how scared the market is. It's that the number is reflecting a month that has already happened.

FAQ

Does a Fear & Greed reading of 10 mean the bottom is in?

There's little basis for that. Half of the index is past-30-day volatility and momentum, so it tends to read low after any sharp drop. In the CoinStats analysis, 90-day outcomes after 25 sub-10 clusters ranged from −38.4% to +100%.

Top traders are about 90% short. Should I short too?

This article isn't a basis for that decision. The 30-day group is re-picked from the past 30 days' results, so in a falling market accounts holding shorts dominate it. Current positions describe the present, not the future direction.

Unrealized profit fell even though price went lower. Why?

Shorts may have been closed to lock in profit, or the 30-day ranking may have changed and brought in other accounts. Snapshot totals can't tell the two apart. Over the same period, the 30-day group's short exposure fell 31%.


See it yourself on the Satoshi Index

The Satoshi Index shows how much the 24-hour, 7-day and 30-day top traders on Hyperliquid, Lighter, dYdX and Pacifica are holding long and short, coin by coin.

You can see long and short account counts, notional value and unrealized PnL for each window, and no login is required.

Data: Fear & Greed Index from alternative.me, daily values Nov 11–20, 2026 (updated 00:00 UTC), cross-checked with a CoinStats analysis dated Nov 16. BTC prices are Hyperliquid daily opens (00:00 UTC) and the Oct 21 close. Satoshi Index 30-day group = top 100 per exchange across four exchanges; Nov 11–19 from morning daily snapshots (05:19–08:09 KST), Nov 20 from a 13:14 KST snapshot. This content is market-data analysis, not investment advice.

‹ Blog

Satoshi Note is a free crypto portfolio tracker by TokenPost. It brings holdings, P&L and trade history from 13 exchanges into one screen and shows what top Hyperliquid, Lighter, dYdX and Pacifica traders hold right now. Open Satoshi Note